php hit counter

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Who many acquire easements Owner or person in possession?
VU Help • House Banner VU Help Virtual University Students - Assignments, Solved Papers, GDB & Exam Help Student Help Forum • Collaborative • Free Support
#1
(1) Owner or person in possession: The first part of section 12 provides that an easement can be acquired by the owner of the dominant heritage or by the person in possession of the dominant heritage on behalf of the owner. Whether the easement is acquired by the owner or person in possession, it is acquired for the beneficial enjoyment of the dominant heritage. An occupier of land can acquire easement. AIR 1953 Kutch 33.
(2) Co-owners: The second paragraph of section, 12 provides that a co-owner of a tenement held in joint ownership can acquire an easement, either by grant or by prescription, and on behalf of all the co-owners of the tenement, but independencetly of their consent, and for the beneficial enjoyment of the tenement held in co-ownership. It need only be remarked that a co-owner cannot, without the consent, of other co-owners, create an easement by grant against the tenement held in co-ownership as servient tenement, and that a co-owner cannot, without the consent of other co-owners, extinguish by release, an already existing easement in favour of the tenement held in co-ownership as dominant tenement. A building was sub-divided in three plots, each sub-divided property having separate building. Three owners of sub-divided building agreed to separate drainage or to install separate or joint water connection or to put up partition wall between sub-divided portions. Such agreement, however, did not envisage use of passage of buildings as common access to all the three owners of adjoining buildings in their respective rear portions. . [/B]
(3) Trespassers: Though the words “any person in possession of the same” are wide enough to include a trespasser within their meaning, it cannot be definitely said that a trespasser, in accepting a grant, or in taking steps to prescribe, can be through of as acting on behalf of the real owner within the meaning of the words “on his behalf” in the first paragraph of this section. These words “on his behalf” are not confined in their meaning to the interpretation that an easement once acquired ensures for the benefit of the owner of the dominant tenement but also lay down that any steps, by way of acceptance of grant, or by way of staring and continuing a user intended to ripen into an easement by the lapse of the statutory period, which the possessor of the tenement may take for the acquisition of the easement, must also be “on behalf” of the dominant owner. The position taken up in the last sentence has its justification because it is inconceivable that a dominant owner who has power to extinguish an easement by express release, cannot have the power to prohibit the person in possession his tenement from acquiring an easement on his behalf, and for the beneficial enjoyment of his tenement. And if that is so, it is difficult to see whether the trespasser who is illegally in possession of the tenement can, in the absence of express authority to acquire an easement, act for that purpose “on behalf” of the owner. Moreover the fact that it takes twelve years for a trespasser to acquire a title to the tenement by adverse possession, but more than twenty years to prescribe for an easement, might introduce additional difficulties in a case when a dominant owner claims an easement by prescription established partly or wholly trough user by a trespasser.
(4) Lessees: A lessee in possession of the dominant tenement can acquire an easement for his lessor in a serivent tenement. The third part of section 12 provides that a lessee cannot acquire in the leased land an easement for the beneficial enjoyment of other land of the lessee. Nor can lessee acquire for the beneficial enjoyment of the leased land an easement over the adjoining land of the lessor. There can be no easement between landlord and tenant. The right of easement could only be acquired by the owner of buildings. A lessee not being owner of the building could not acquire such right against. A lessor over adjoining the property owned by such lessor.1987 MLD 461. A lessee of the land which he has taken for building purposes is not in the position of an owner of immovable property under section 12, easements act for the purpose of a right-of-way by easement over other land owned by his lessee. AIR 1938 All. 293.
(5) Co-tenants: It is clear that the tenant of land can acquire an easement against property held by another tenant belonging to someone other than his own lossor. AIR 1920 All. 862.
(6) prescription: A building was sub-divided in three plots, each sub-divided property having separate building. Three owners of sub-divided building agreed to separate drainage or to install separate or joint water connection or to put up partition wall between sub-divided portions. Such agreement, however, did not envisage use of passage of building as common access to all the three owners of adjoining building in their respective rear portions. One of sub-divided buildings was sold to a third party. The purchaser attempted to close gap between buildings. Such attempt led to dispute between purchaser and other owners of sub-divided buildings. The plaintiff filed a suit for declaration and mandatory injunction restraining the defendants from using open space of property as passage for access to rear portion of their buildings. The plaintiff and their predecessor-in-title always disputed rights of defendants and their predecessor-in-title to use open space of buildings as passage for going over to rear portions of building. During period when matter was pending in the court mere user of open space as an access to rear portion of building by tenants could not create any right of easement by prescription in favour of the defendants. In order to acquire a right-of-way as an easement or any other easement right by prescription it must be shown that such right had been enjoyed actually, openly, peaceably, without interruption by any person claiming title thereto as an easement and as of right for more than twenty years. 1985 CLC 158.
Right of easement to flow water- - grant of: It is clear that a right of easement could not be granted to the plaintiff if the plaintiff claimed the land over which he claimed a right as belonging to him. The question of animus was a question of fact. A person claiming to be owner of a land had the animus of an owner and not the animus of a person exercising a right of easement over the land of another. Although a right of easement could be claimed in the alternative if the plaintiff primarily claimed to be owner also and in the alternative pleaded that in case he was not proved to be owner of the land and the defendant was held to be owner thereof then in that event a right of easement might be granted to him as he had been flowing water and doing other acts as of easement. 1984 AWC 198.
Dispute between parties being basically about demarcation of land: According to the case of Ghulam Ahmad v. Muhammad Yousaf Khan, P. S.D .,PLD 1986 (AJ & K) 214,the applicant failed to get his portion of land demarcation and constructed house without demarcation of land. Demarcation if done now might disturb other allottees and some of them might have to demolish their houses for the negligence and slackness of persons who were not careful and slept over their rights. Law aids the vigilant and not those who sleep over their rights.
Temporary injunction: Petitioner or the persons occupying his property had never been using the disputed passage nor their property had any opening on respondent’s side. Interference in the orders of refusal of temporary injunction passed by courts below regarding respondents threats to close the passage by raising a wall would not be justified in exercise of revisional jurisdiction. 1990 CLC 851.
Exercise of revisional jurisdiction: Person in immediate neighbourhood, entitled to use a local public thoroughfare, had a special cause of action irrespective of fact that he had proved special damage or not. Principal being that a person of immediate vicinity or section of public who was deprived of amenity provided for that particular section may be deemed to have suffered loss without proof of special damage. Inhabitants of vicinity of thoroughfare or residents of village would be entitled to seek removal of obstruction without proving special damage. The appellate court below ignored above-noted principal of law and laboured under misconception of law reversed findings of the Trial court. Said appellate court is accepting appeal and in dismissing suit of petitioner, therefore, exercised jurisdiction illegally. The high court in exercise of revisional jurisdiction set aside judgment and the decree passed by the said appellate court in circumstances. 1988 CLC 1301. Memo of constitutional petition indicated that though petitioners had made a reference to the infringement of their rights of privacy which had been guaranteed by the constitution, they had also referred in extensor the non-performance of statutory duty by official respondents. Such petition thus could not be deemed to be for the enforcement of easement right simpliciter adjudication of which would involve disputed question of fact but for the enforcement of statutory duty cast upon official respondent. Petitioners prime facie thus had locus standi to file the petition.1090 C LC 83.
Right of easement may be acquired is supply of sullage water to zamindars: In the case of Huesain Din v. Abdul Jabbar, PLD 1952 Lah. 411, the Municipal Corporation had made permanent arrangements for sale of sullage water from their reservoirs to zamindars and it was sold to them if and when they applied, in the normal course, without much difficulty. Only a specified payment had to be made. In these circumstances of the case, it was held that it could not be said that the course of irrigation water was of a temporary character or so precarious that no right of easement could arise between the two appropriators situated on the extension of the channel leading from the Municipal reservoirs, inter se. The mere fact that right of easement, if one was established.
Inchoate right not protected by law: An inchoate right, so large as such right remains incomplete and does not open into easement is not protected by law. PLD 1971 Kar. 701.


Attached Files
.doc   24 Who many acquire easements.doc (Size: 35 KB / Downloads: 207)
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Pleadings and proof in easements vustudents 0 3,670 05-02-2012, 01:50 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  What are “Other easements “ in law of easements vustudents 0 8,058 05-02-2012, 01:15 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  What do u understand about Easements of necessity vustudents 0 3,925 05-01-2012, 02:57 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  Easements arise only on severance vustudents 0 3,860 05-01-2012, 02:44 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  . Discuss and differentiate Easements of necessity and quasi-easements? vustudents 0 4,025 05-01-2012, 02:28 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  Who may acquire easements in general ? vustudents 0 2,999 05-01-2012, 02:09 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  . what is meant by Lessor and mortgagor in easements? vustudents 0 3,064 05-01-2012, 01:25 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  What are Modes of creation & acquisition of easements? vustudents 0 5,665 05-01-2012, 12:52 AM
Last Post: vustudents
  What are Riparian rights in easements? vustudents 0 4,033 04-30-2012, 09:55 PM
Last Post: vustudents
  What is Imposition acquisition and transfer of easements? vustudents 0 3,693 04-30-2012, 09:41 PM
Last Post: vustudents

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
VU Help • House Banner VU Help Virtual University Students - Assignments, Solved Papers, GDB & Exam Help Student Help Forum • Collaborative • Free Support